Brand Story
15 Apr 2021, 20:42 GMT+10
In May 2019, I wrote an article discussing the state of patent-eligible and patent-ineligible subject matter and its impact on casino gaming innovations. See "Gaming Patents and 'Abstract Ideas': What Are the Rules of the Game?", Casino & Gaming International 37:35-40 (May 2, 2019); available at https://issuu.com/cgimagazine/docs/2019-2. In short, mathematical algorithms, mental processes and rules of a game constitute "abstract ideas" that are patent-ineligible subject matter.
Roughly two years on, it is time to revisit the state of the law.
A few very recent Federal Circuit decisions are worth examining, as they provide some additional guideposts regarding what is and is not patent-eligible subject matter. First, Cxloyalty, Inc. v. Maritz Holdings Inc., No. 2020-1307 (Fed. Cir. Feb. 8, 2021), involved a graphical user interface between a consumer, a loyalty program and a vendor. One could envision such an invention, perhaps, between a casino patron, a players' rewards program and a third-party, partner restaurant or hotel at which comps could be used (or earned through patronage).
PTAB found that the invention was directed to an abstract idea of a broker but concluded that the business method claims were eligible under step two of Alice.1 Specifically, PTAB appears to have relied heavily on the fact that the patentee submitted expert testimony to support the allowed claim. In reversing, the Federal Circuit found that the claims do not survive under Alice step two, as the limitations in question did not constitute a patent-eligible technological solution to a technical problem.
Moreover, while the expert testimony may have supported a finding of "novel" subject matter, "a patent claim is not eligible under § 101 merely because it recites novel subject matter." Indeed, under Alice step two, where an abstract idea uses wholly conventional techniques "specified at a high degree of generality," a claim cannot be pulled into the realm of patent-eligible subject matter.
Next, came a series of two related cases. In re Board of Trustee of the Leland Stanford Junior Univ., No. 2020-1012 (Fed. Cir. Mar. 11, 2021), involved improved haplotype phasing techniques.2 PTAB determined that the claims were directed to either the "mental steps of receiving, storing, or providing information" or "mathematical concepts." Specifically, PTAB found that the claims did not improve computer technology but rather used off-the-shelf computing equipment to perform an improved mathematical analysis.
The Federal Circuit affirmed, concluding that the claims were drawn to abstract mathematical calculations. Further, the court held that storing and providing information on request was inadequate under Alice step two, explaining that it was "hard to imagine" a more generic description of claim limitations related to hardware.
For the gaming industry, the takeaway reinforces much of what we thought we have known-the mathematical processes and statistics behind casino games are not likely where an innovation's patent-eligible subject matter will be found.
The follow-on case, In re Board of Trustees of the Leland Stanford Junior Univ., No. 2020-1288 (Fed. Cir. Mar. 25, 2021), involved computerized statistical methods for determining haplotype phase. PTAB determined that the claim was directed to mathematical concepts-i.e., mathematical relationship, formulas, equations and calculation. Further, PTAB determined that the claim recited two abstract mental processes-receiving and storing genotype data in a computer memory-and concluded that the claim included no specific steps applying the series of computations in a practical way (i.e., resulting in improved computer functionality).
In affirming, the Federal Circuit explained that (Alice step one) a "different use of a mathematical calculation, even one that yields different or better results, does not render patent eligible subject matter." At Alice step two, the court concluded that the claims were abstract calculations appended to well-understood, routine and conventional steps for haplotype extraction and data storage, explaining that the application of those elements was itself a patent-ineligible mathematical analysis.
Again, the takeaway is: When seeking patent protection for innovations in the gaming space, look for patentable subject matter in areas other than the rules of the game, the statistics underlying a game and the mathematical processes that are often interwoven into casino games.
In sum, two years later, we are in about the same place regarding patent-eligible and patent-ineligible subject matter. That reinforces the need-when protecting a product, and especially a product in the casino gaming space-for a comprehensive intellectual property protection strategy.
Such a strategy should employ coverage involving all of the IP disciplines, including patents, trademarks, copyrights, and even, potentially, trade secrets.
Resources
1Under Alice step one, claims that "focus on a specific means or method that improves the relevant technology" (such as "an improved cardiac monitoring device" that uses unconventional techniques to detect atrial fibrillation and atrial flutter) typically pass, and claims that "are instead directed to a result or effect that itself is the abstract idea and merely invoke generic processes and machinery" (such as a method "for detecting fraud in financial transactions during a payment clearing process" using a computer) do not. See CardioNet, LLC v. InfoBionic, Inc., 955 F.3d 1358 (Fed. Cir. 2020); Bozeman Fin. LLC v. Fed. Reserve Bank of Atlanta, 955 F.3d 971, 978-980 (Fed. Cir. 2020). Under Alice step two, claims in which the only non-abstract elements are "conventional, off-the-shelf computer components" are usually doomed to fail. Id.
2"Haplotype phasing is a process for determining the parent from whom alleles-i.e., versions of a genes-are inherited. A haplotype phase acts as an indication of the parent from whom a gene has been inherited."
About Martensen IPAt the intersection of business, law and technology, Martensen understands the tools of IP. Martensen knows the business of IP. We understand the tech market, especially when the government is a customer, and we know how to plan, assess, and adjust. Patents, trademarks, copyrights, trade secrets, licenses are our tools.
Martensen IP Media ContactMike Martensen | Founder(719) 358-2254
Get a daily dose of Detroit Star news through our daily email, its complimentary and keeps you fully up to date with world and business news as well.
Publish news of your business, community or sports group, personnel appointments, major event and more by submitting a news release to Detroit Star.
More InformationMADRID, Spain: Liverpool footballer Diogo Jota and his younger brother, André Silva, have died in a car accident in Spain. Spanish...
LONDON, U.K.: An unrelenting heatwave sweeping across Europe has pushed early summer temperatures to historic highs, triggering deadly...
President Donald Trump's plans to build a space-based Golden Dome missile defense shield have drawn immediate criticism from China,...
NEW YORK CITY, New York: Paramount has agreed to pay US$16 million to settle a lawsuit brought by U.S. President Donald Trump over...
LONDON, U.K.: British Prime Minister Keir Starmer won a vote in Parliament this week to move ahead with changes to the country's welfare...
WASHINGTON, D.C.: President Donald Trump will meet Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu at the White House on Monday. President...
(Photo credit: David Richard-Imagn Images) Riley Greene, Javier Baez and Gleyber Torres will start in the All-Star Game this month,...
(Photo credit: Eric Canha-Imagn Images) Boston right-hander Walker Buehler looks to put a horrid six-start stretch behind him when...
(Photo credit: Kamil Krzaczynski-Imagn Images) The Chicago Cubs set a franchise record by bashing eight home runs in a single game...
(Photo credit: Michael C. Johnson-Imagn Images) Felix Ojo, a five-star offensive tackle, will stay in his home state of Texas after...
(Photo credit: Ken Blaze-Imagn Images) Wenceel Perez and Zach McKinstry hit solo home runs and four Detroit pitchers combined for...
(Photo credit: Chadd Cady-Imagn Images) The Tampa Bay Rays will begin their long, strange trip to the All-Star break when they face...